PEG vs PEGY Ratio: Which Valuation Metric Should You Use?

When it comes to stock valuation, two powerful metrics often cause confusion: the PEG ratio and the PEGY ratio. Both improve on the basic P/E ratio by incorporating growth, but they're designed for different types of stocks. This guide will help you understand when to use each—and why it matters for your investment returns.

The Quick Answer

Use PEG for: Non-dividend growth stocks (tech, biotech, high-growth companies)
Use PEGY for: Dividend-paying stocks (utilities, REITs, mature companies)

But let's dive deeper into why this distinction matters and how each ratio works.

Understanding the PEG Ratio

The Formula

PEG Ratio = P/E Ratio ÷ Earnings Growth Rate

What PEG Tells You

The PEG ratio shows whether you're paying a fair price for a company's growth potential. It answers the question: "Am I overpaying for this growth stock?"

Interpretation:

• PEG < 1.0: Potentially undervalued
• PEG = 1.0: Fairly valued
• PEG > 2.0: Potentially overvalued

PEG Ratio Example

High-Growth Tech Company:

• P/E Ratio: 40
• Earnings Growth: 35%
• PEG = 40 / 35 = 1.14 - Fairly valued

Without the PEG ratio, a P/E of 40 looks expensive. But when you're getting 35% growth, it's actually reasonable!

When PEG Works Best

• Growth stocks with minimal or no dividends
• Technology companies reinvesting profits
• Emerging sectors with high growth rates
• Comparing growth stocks within same industry
• Capital appreciation focused investing

PEG Limitations

• Ignores dividend yield completely
• Misleading for dividend stocks - makes them look overvalued
• Doesn't work for unprofitable companies (no P/E ratio)
• Growth estimate dependent - garbage in, garbage out

Understanding the PEGY Ratio

The Formula

PEGY Ratio = P/E Ratio ÷ (Earnings Growth Rate + Dividend Yield)

What PEGY Tells You

The PEGY ratio shows whether you're paying a fair price for a company's total return potential (growth + dividend income). It answers: "What total return am I getting for this valuation?"

Interpretation:

• PEGY < 1.0: Potentially undervalued
• PEGY = 1.0-1.5: Fairly valued
• PEGY > 2.0: Potentially overvalued

PEGY Ratio Example

Dividend-Paying Utility:

• P/E Ratio: 20
• Earnings Growth: 6%
• Dividend Yield: 4.5%
• PEGY = 20 / (6 + 4.5) = 1.90 - Reasonably valued

This stock offers 10.5% total return potential (6% growth + 4.5% yield), making a P/E of 20 fair.

When PEGY Works Best

• Dividend-paying stocks of any yield level
• Mature companies with slower growth
• Utilities and REITs with substantial yields
• Income-focused portfolios
• Comparing stocks with different dividend policies
• Total return analysis

PEGY Limitations

• Unnecessary complexity for non-dividend stocks
• Dividend sustainability not factored in
• May favor unsustainable high yields
• Still relies on growth estimates

Head-to-Head Comparison

The Same Stock, Different Metrics

Let's see how a dividend stock looks through each lens:

Blue-Chip Consumer Staples Company:

• P/E Ratio: 22
• Earnings Growth: 8%
• Dividend Yield: 3.5%

Using PEG:
PEG = 22 / 8 = 2.75 (Looks very overvalued!)

Using PEGY:
PEGY = 22 / (8 + 3.5) = 1.91 (Fairly valued!)

The Insight: PEG makes this quality dividend stock appear expensive, while PEGY reveals it offers reasonable 11.5% total return potential.

When Each Metric Gives WRONG Signals

PEG's Blind Spot: Dividend Stocks

Example: Established Telecom

• P/E: 14
• Growth: 3%
• Dividend: 7%
• PEG = 4.67 (looks terrible!)
• PEGY = 1.40 (actually decent!)

Reality: Despite 10% total return potential, PEG makes this stock look absurdly overvalued.

PEGY's Blind Spot: Unsustainable Dividends

Example: Distressed Energy Company

• P/E: 12
• Growth: -2%
• Dividend: 9% (payout ratio: 110%!)
• PEG = -6.0 (undefined/useless)
• PEGY = 1.71 (looks okay, but it's a trap!)

Reality: The 9% yield is unsustainable. PEGY looks "reasonable" but dividend will be cut, destroying value.

Decision Framework: Which Ratio to Use

Use PEG Ratio When:

Example Sectors: Software, biotech, early-stage tech, e-commerce

Use PEGY Ratio When:

Mistake #2: Using PEGY for Non-Dividend Stocks

Problem: Adds no value, identical to PEG
Solution: Stick with PEG for 0% yielders

Mistake #3: Ignoring Dividend Sustainability

Problem: PEGY can't distinguish safe vs risky yields
Solution: Always check payout ratio and FCF

Mistake #4: Comparing Across Metrics

Problem: Can't compare a PEG of 1.0 to a PEGY of 1.0
Solution: Use same metric within comparison set

Mistake #5: Forgetting Growth Quality

Problem: Both metrics assume growth will materialize
Solution: Verify revenue growth, margins, competitive position

Advanced: Combining PEG and PEGY

For stocks with 2-4% yields, looking at both ratios provides deeper insights:

Example: Industrial Dividend Grower

• P/E: 18
• Growth: 12%
• Dividend: 2.8%

PEG: 18 / 12 = 1.50 (moderately valued)
PEGY: 18 / 14.8 = 1.22 (better value)

Insight: The 2.8% dividend improves value proposition by 19% (PEGY vs PEG). If you value income, this is more attractive than PEG alone suggests.

Sector Best Practices

Technology

Preferred: PEG
Typical Range: 0.8 - 1.5
Why: Minimal dividends, growth is everything

Utilities

Preferred: PEGY
Typical Range: 1.2 - 1.8
Why: 4-5% yields, modest 5-7% growth

Consumer Staples

Preferred: PEGY
Typical Range: 1.4 - 2.0
Why: 2-4% yields, slow but steady growth

Healthcare

Preferred: Both (subsector dependent)
Typical Range: PEG 1.0-1.6, PEGY 1.2-1.8
Why: Mix of growth (biotech) and income (pharma)

REITs

Preferred: PEGY
Typical Range: 1.3 - 2.0
Why: 4-6% required distributions, moderate growth

Quick Reference Guide

PEG Ratio Cheat Sheet

*Verify with additional research

PEGY Ratio Cheat Sheet

• Both metrics improve on basic P/E by incorporating growth
• Neither is "better" - they serve different purposes
• Always verify dividend sustainability when using PEGY
• Compare within sectors using the same metric
• Look at both for 1-3% yielders to see complete picture

Next Steps

Master stock valuation with both metrics:

• Calculate PEG and PEGY ratios for any stock instantly
• Deep dive into PEG ratio for growth stocks
• Learn PEGY ratio for dividend investing
• Explore all 5 valuation metrics for comprehensive analysis
• Screen AI stocks with PEG in 2025's tech boom
• Find dividend value with PEGY in falling rate environment

---

Disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Both PEG and PEGY ratios rely on future earnings growth estimates which may not materialize. No single metric guarantees investment success. Always conduct comprehensive research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions. Past performance does not guarantee future results.