Stock Valuation in Bull vs Bear Markets: Adapting Your PEG Strategy

Market conditions dramatically affect which stocks offer the best opportunities. Using the same valuation approach in bull markets and bear markets is like wearing the same clothes in summer and winter - it doesn't work. This guide shows you how to adapt your PEG ratio strategy for different market environments.

Why Market Context Matters for Valuation

The same stock can be:

• Expensive in a bull market (but still goes higher)
• Cheap in a bear market (and still gets cheaper)

Understanding how to adjust valuation thresholds for market conditions prevents:

• Missing opportunities in bull markets
• Catching falling knives in bear markets
• Selling too early in recoveries
• Holding too long in downturns

Understanding the Market Cycle

The Four Phases

1. Bull Market / Expansion

• Rising stock prices (20%+ from lows)
• Economic growth accelerating
• Corporate earnings increasing
• Investor confidence high
• Valuations expanding

2. Market Peak / Late Cycle

• Euphoria and excessive optimism
• Valuations at historical highs
• Speculation increasing
• Warning signs emerging

3. Bear Market / Contraction

• Declining prices (-20%+ from peak)
• Economic growth slowing
• Earnings disappointing
• Fear dominating sentiment
• Valuations compressing

4. Market Bottom / Early Recovery

• Maximum pessimism
• Valuations at historical lows
• Economic indicators stabilizing
• Quality stocks oversold

Where Are We in 2025? Early 2025 shows characteristics of late-cycle expansion with pockets of valuation excess, suggesting defensive positioning alongside selective growth opportunities.

PEG Ratio Strategy by Market Phase

Bull Market Strategy (Rising Tide Phase)

Market Characteristics:

• S&P 500: 20%+ above 200-day MA
• VIX:< 5 (low volatility)
• Economic growth: Accelerating
• Earnings revisions: Trending upward

PEG Ratio Adjustments:

Standard Threshold: PEG< .0
Bull Market Threshold: PEG< .5 (more lenient)

Why: In bull markets, stocks with "fair" valuations continue rising as earnings growth accelerates and multiple expansion occurs.

Sector Focus in Bull Markets:

Most Attractive:

• Technology: PEG< .0 acceptable
• Consumer Discretionary: PEG< .7
• Industrials: PEG< .4
• Small-Caps: PEG< .6

Less Attractive:

• Utilities: Underperform in growth phase
• Consumer Staples: Too defensive
• Bonds/REITs: Interest rate headwinds

Example Bull Market Stock:

High-Growth SaaS Company (2024):

• P/E: 45
• Growth: 35%
• PEG: 45 / 35 = 1.29

Assessment:

• In bear market: Overvalued (prefer PEG< .0)
• In bull market: Acceptable (threshold 1.5)
• Action: Buy with conviction

Bull Market Tactics:

1. Momentum + Value Combo:

• PEG < 1.5
• Price> 0-day MA
• Earnings estimate revisions positive

2. Growth Over Value:

• Favor 20%+ growth even at PEG 1.3
• Avoid slow growers even with PEG 0.8

3. Quality Matters More:

• Focus on market leaders
• Pay up for competitive moats
• Accept premium valuations

4. Longer Holding Periods:

• Let winners run
• Trim only on fundamental deterioration
• Don't sell on PEG expansion alone

Bear Market Strategy (Capital Preservation Phase)

Market Characteristics:

• S&P 500: 20%+ below peak
• VIX:> 5 (high volatility)
• Economic growth: Slowing
• Earnings revisions: Trending downward

PEG Ratio Adjustments:

Standard Threshold: PEG< .0
Bear Market Threshold: PEG< .7 (more conservative)

Why: In bear markets, even "cheap" stocks get cheaper. Only buy the cheapest of the cheap, and wait for stabilization.

Sector Focus in Bear Markets:

Most Defensive:

• Utilities: PEG< .0
• Consumer Staples: PEG< .2
• Healthcare: PEG< .0
• High-Quality Dividends: PEGY< .3

Avoid:

• High-growth unprofitable tech
• Cyclical industrials
• Leveraged companies
• Speculative small-caps

Example Bear Market Approach:

Defensive Utility (During 2022 Bear):

• P/E: 15
• Growth: 6%
• Dividend Yield: 4.5%
• PEGY: 15 / (6 + 4.5) = 1.43

Assessment:

• In bull market: Too defensive, underperforms
• In bear market: Ideal - income + stability
• Action: Build position gradually

Bear Market Tactics:

1. Extreme Value Only:

• PEG< .7 for growth stocks
• PEGY< .2 for dividend stocks
• Prefer negative PEG screens (bottom-fishing)

2. Dividend Safety Priority:

• Payout ratio< 0%
• FCF covers dividend 1.5x+
• 10+ years dividend growth history

3. Balance Sheet Strength:

• Debt/Equity< .5
• Interest coverage> x
• Positive free cash flow

4. Dollar-Cost Averaging:

• Buy in thirds over 3-6 months
• Average into cheap stocks as they fall
• Keep cash reserves for further declines

5. Shorter Holding Periods:

• Quick to sell on rallies
• Take profits at PEG 1.2-1.3
• Rotate to safer names

Market Bottom Strategy (Maximum Opportunity Phase)

Market Characteristics:

• Extreme pessimism (capitulation)
• VIX: 35-50+ (panic levels)
• Sentiment indicators: Max bearish
• Quality stocks at decade-low valuations

PEG Ratio Signals:

Market Bottom Indicators:

• High-quality stocks: PEG< .5
• Dividend aristocrats: PEGY< .8
• Market leaders: PEG< .7

Historical Example: March 2020 COVID Bottom:

Many quality names briefly traded at:

• P/E: 12-15 (depressed earnings)
• Growth potential: 15-20% (recovery baked in)
• PEG: 0.6-0.8 (screaming bargains)

Bottom Fishing Strategy:

1. Build Shopping List in Advance:

• Identify 20-30 quality companies
• Set target PEG levels (< 0.8)
• Have cash ready (20-40% portfolio)

2. Scale In Aggressively:

• Buy 25% when PEG< .0
• Buy 25% when PEG< .8
• Buy 25% when PEG< .6
• Buy 25% on panic days

3. Focus on Survivors:

• Large-cap leaders
• Fortress balance sheets (low debt)
• Essential businesses
• Proven recession track records

4. Buy Basket, Not Individual Bets:

• Diversify across 15-20 stocks
• Cover multiple sectors
• Odds of catching exact bottom low: Buy the dip

Late-Cycle Strategy (Caution Phase)

Market Characteristics:

• S&P 500 P/E: 22+ (above average)
• Economic growth: Peaking
• Interest rates: Rising
• Yield curve: Flattening or inverting

PEG Ratio Adjustments:

Standard Threshold: PEG< .0
Late-Cycle Threshold: PEG< .8 + Balance Sheet Focus

Why: Valuations typically peak before markets, so requiring extra margin of safety protects capital.

Late-Cycle Priorities:

1. Shift to Quality:

• Prefer PEG 0.9 with ROE> 0%
• Over PEG 0.7 with ROE< 0%

2. Reduce Leverage Exposure:

• Avoid Debt/Equity> .0
• Seek free cash flow generators
• Companies that can weather downturn

3. Add Recession-Resistant Names:

• Dividend aristocrats
• Essential services
• Non-discretionary spending

4. Trim Euphoric Winners:

• Sell stocks with PEG> .5
• Take profits on speculative plays
• Reduce position sizes to 3-4% max

Sector Rotation by Market Phase

Growth Phase (Bull Market Early-Mid)

Overweight:

• Technology (PEG threshold: 1.6)
• Consumer Discretionary (PEG threshold: 1.4)
• Industrials (PEG threshold: 1.3)

Target: 60-70% of portfolio

Underweight:

• Utilities (too defensive)
• Consumer Staples (too defensive)
• REITs (rate-sensitive)

Slowdown Phase (Late Cycle / Early Bear)

Balanced:

• 30% Growth (PEG< .2)
• 40% Quality Value (PEG< .0, High ROE)
• 30% Defensive (PEGY< .3)

Increase Cash: 10-20%

Recession Phase (Bear Market)

Overweight:

• Consumer Staples (PEGY< .2)
• Utilities (PEGY< .0)
• Healthcare (PEG< .0)

Target: 50-60% defensive

Cash: 20-30% for opportunities

Recovery Phase (Bull Market Early)

Overweight:

• Cyclicals (PEG< .8)
• Financials (PEG< .9)
• Small-Caps (PEG< .0)
• Emerging Leaders (PEG< .3)

Deploy Cash: Aggressively

Real-World Case Study: 2020-2023 Market Cycle

March 2020: Market Bottom

Situation:

• COVID panic
• S&P 500 down 34%
• VIX: 82 (record)

Opportunities:

• Microsoft: PEG 1.1 (normally 2.0+)
• Apple: PEG 0.95 (normally 1.8+)
• Healthcare names: PEG 0.7-0.9

Strategy: Buy quality at PEG< .0 aggressively

Result: 50-100%+ gains in 12 months

2021: Bull Market Peak

Situation:

• Euphoria in tech/SPACs
• Valuations stretched
• Speculation rampant

Warning Signs:

• Unprofitable tech: PEG infinite
• Profitable tech: PEG 2.5-4.0
• Speculative names: PEG 5.0+

Strategy: Should have raised cash, trimmed winners

Result: Those who didn't trim faced -50% to -80% in 2022

2022: Bear Market

Situation:

• Rate hikes
• Recession fears
• Tech selling

Opportunities Mid-Year:

• Quality tech: PEG 0.8-1.2 (from 2.5+)
• Defensive stocks: PEGY 1.0-1.3

Strategy: Accumulate slowly at PEG< .0

Result: 2023 recovery captured gains

2023-2024: Selective Bull

Situation:

• AI boom
• Mega-cap leadership
• Rest of market lagging

Strategy:

• AI names: Accepted PEG 1.5-2.0
• Rest: Strict PEG< .2
• Rotation to quality value

Adapting PEG Thresholds: Quick Reference

How to Identify Current Market Phase

Use Multiple Indicators:

1. Price Trend:

• Bull: S&P 500> 00-day MA by 10%+
• Bear: S&P 500< 00-day MA by 10%+

2. Volatility (VIX):

• Bull/Calm: VIX< 5
• Moderate: VIX 15-25
• Bear/Fear: VIX> 5
• Panic: VIX> 5

3. Breadth:

• Healthy: 60%+ stocks above 200-day MA
• Weakening: 40-60%
• Bear:< 0%

4. Sentiment:

• Bullish Extreme: AAII Bulls> 5%
• Bearish Extreme: AAII Bears> 5%

5. Valuation (S&P 500 P/E):

• Cheap:< 6
• Fair: 16-20
• Expensive: 20-22
• Very Expensive:> 2

Current 2025 Assessment: Mix of late-cycle (high valuations) and early recovery (AI theme) suggests selective approach with defensive hedges.

Key Takeaways

• Adapt PEG thresholds to market conditions - what's cheap in a bull differs from a bear
• Bull markets: Accept PEG up to 1.5 for quality growth
• Bear markets: Demand PEG< .7 and strong balance sheets
• Late cycle: Raise cash and quality standards - margin of safety critical
• Market bottoms: Deploy aggressively at PEG< .9 for quality names
• Sector rotation matters - own cyclicals in recovery, defensives in recession
• Balance sheet quality increases in importance during downturns

Next Steps for Market-Aware Investing

• Master PEG ratio fundamentals before applying market-specific strategies
• Learn defensive PEGY approach for bear markets
• Screen for quality stocks at attractive valuations
• Avoid valuation mistakes across all market conditions
• Compare value vs growth in different cycles

---

Disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Predicting market cycles is extremely difficult, and strategies that worked historically may not work in the future. Bear markets can last longer and go deeper than expected. All investments carry risk of loss. Always conduct comprehensive research, maintain appropriate diversification, and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.